I truly want to know your opinions on this folks.
What do you think are the "rules" to cell phones and their boundaries? I don't mean when and where you talk on one (which could be a whole other post) but in the phone as an item belonging to someone else.
Here are the questions (the assumption is the other person
hasn't asked you to do these things):
- Should you answer someone else's cell phone? When is is okay and when is it not? (if ever.)
- Should you look at another person's cell phone to see who is calling?
- Should you look at someone's texts?
- Should you look at another person's call history?
- Should you look to see who they have in their contacts folder?
I'd be really interested to hear your opinions and reasons. Please comment below. I'm going to share my thoughts and I'd love to read a give and take of ideas.
You see, as a therapist I'm constantly teaching people about boundaries. I'm forever talking about what is appropriate and inappropriate boundaries. I work on helping couples see when either is stepping out-of-bounds and how to stay in-bounds.
Breach of privacy is a boundary violation. Period. If you invade someone's privacy
without invitation, you are acting in an un-relational and unhealthy manner. Examples are going through someone's personal papers, reading their diary, reading their email, looking at financial papers, etc.- all without invitation.
So, in this definition,
doing any of the things I asked about above are boundary violations. They cross a line into someone else's personal "space". In short, doing any of those things means you are being nosy, invasive and acting untrustworthy. None of these things is good for a relationship.
I won't look at my husband's phone when it is ringing to see who it is. If he is out of the room I just inform him the phone is ringing (or rang if he is out) and leave it at that. It is not my business to know who was calling. He respects my phone in the same manner.
When someone asks you to do these things, it isn't a violation. Sometimes (like when he is driving) my husband will ask me to see who is calling. He may even ask me to answer the call. That is okay because he has given me permission to be in his personal space.
There are also times when there is an agreement that doing one or more of these things is okay. For example, some couples who have suffered through an affair will have an agreement the phone is available at any time for review, but that is part of the healing process.
Another time it may be appropriate is if you share a cell phone. Obviously, like a home land-line, the phone is then communal property. If you pay for someone else's phone (your child, your partner, etc.) then you need to clarify the rules around privacy. If you intend to look at the phone and feel it is your right as the "owner" then the other person needs to know this.
I regularly run into individuals who think it is okay to look at, answer, or read through another person's phone- especially if they are dating or married. Because the cell phone is ubiquitous, they forget it
is another person's private property. In addition, they have the opinion "if he/she isn't doing anything wrong they have nothing to worry about."
It is still an invasion. Imagine someone reading your most private journal or diary, even if there is nothing "wrong" in it. It is hurtful and harmful and it is not good boundaries.
If you want to look at someone's phone, you need to ask permission. In addition, you need to respect their right to say "No" to your request. They have a right to their boundaries.
This may seem trivial, but I believe the way you handle the little things (like the phone) represents how you handle the bigger things (like personal boundaries.) If you disrespect your partner's phone privacy, you are more likely to have poor boundaries elsewhere. You are more likely to be un-relational in other ways.
Well, you have now heard my thoughts on this matter, what do you think?
What are the "rules" to cell phones and their boundaries?
Click the comment button below and express yourself about cell privacy!